Public humiliation, the way to go?

I read this article on stuff.co.nz yesterday and thought it was blog-worthy.

FYI, for those not familiar with the term “tagger”, it refers to somebody who graffitis walls, fences, public toilets etc.

Taggers in pink while cleaning up their work

Forcing taggers to wear pink vests as punishment reduces tagging, a Wellington policeman says.

Eastern Suburbs Community Constable Theo Gommans introduced the vests with the support and funding of Wellington City Council and started using them, as a deterrent, in his tagging talks at high schools.

Taggers caught by him or processed through the courts would be made to wear the vests while they cleaned up their handiwork to turn their tagging “fame” into “shame” with their classmates, he said.

Mr Gommans showed the pink vest at Rongotai College last week and was greeted by stunned silence, nervous laughter, then a big round of applause.

He expects a similar response when he visits St Patrick’s Town today.

But councillor Iona Pannett said the scheme was akin to Nazi Germany’s persecution of gay men during World War II and would reinforce prejudice against gay and lesbian people.

“What we’re saying is that we’re going to shame you as a tagger by associating you with a gay man, for a behaviour that has nothing to do with being gay or lesbian.

“Marking out people in that way is something we should move beyond.”

The vests should be withdrawn from talks at schools and another way found to deal with taggers. “There will be young men or young women who are out [as gay] or exploring [their sexuality]. The giggles and the laughter create an unsafe environment.”

An unfazed Mr Gommans said pink was the brightest, most unpopular colour he could think of and had nothing to do with being gay.

Tagging had reduced by 80 per cent in the eastern suburbs since he started using the vests in school talks, alongside a “dob a tagger” initiative, which offered a $100 reward for identifying taggers.

A teenage girl, sentenced to community work in Wellington District Court a fortnight ago, was the first person to don the vest and did so under a storm of protest, he said.

St Patrick’s Town deputy rector Wayne Mills welcomed the initiative, and said Mr Gommans had made a big difference to the community’s graffiti.

“It will certainly send a message out there to kids.”

Mayor Kerry Prendergast said the council supported the vests despite Ms Pannett’s stance.

“I think she’s a lone voice on this issue. If that’s what it takes to stop them literally doing hundreds of thousands of dollars of damage to private and public property then I think it’s a good thing.”

Personally, I think it’s the greatest thing ever. Yes, it’s embarassing, humiliating even, yes, you WILL look like an idiot wearing a bright pink vest with “TAGGER” on it while cleaning up whatever you scribbled on, and people WILL point and laugh at you, but, there’s a simple solution and a way to avoid having to endure that. Don’t graffiti things to begin with!

As for the woman who thinks it ought to be prohibited, that is the most stupid, petty argument I have ever heard. If it proves to be a problem, and LGBT groups themselves voice an objection (which I believe they have yet to do) then fine, make them wear bright GREEN vests or something, I don’t think it’s the colour that’s the issue here, it’s the whole concept of public humiliation as a deterrent.

Opinions please. :)


16 Comments


(Required)
(Required, will not be published)